I look like a witch!

So, I am cleaning up after school, getting ready to go home. There is a student hanging out and she tells me that she loves my hair cut and she wants to cut hers to look the same. Her hair is long and thick and beautiful. I tell her not to cut her hair because hers is so pretty. She tells me her hair is fake and proceeds to 'take it out'. Five minutes later there is a pile of black hair on the desk.
Against my better judgement, I ask her to put the extensions in my hair. I have always wanted extensions and I have been trying to decide if I want to grow my hair out. I thought that if I could see myself with her extensions in I would be better able to decide. The results are a little silly. I think I look like a witch. Maybe it is the black, or maybe it is the length, but I don't think this is a good look for me. What do you think?
For better reference, this is a picture of my current hair cut. Which do you prefer?